Zagat Member Reviews
Ariano's Trattoria
18 Clark Place
Mahopac, NY 10541
Phone: 845-621-0137
Most helpful review submitted by 'RPFESQ'
Our visits to the new location in Carmel have been worthwhile. Brick-oven pizza is crispy with just the right balance of sauce and toppings. Entrees are carefully prepared and flavorful. Specials are worth exploring. When dining-in, the owner makes you feel like you're family. BYOB. Generous portions. Arrive early on weekends or be ready for a wait. Plastic Coke pizza-shop glasses detract from the dining experience. Service is friendly & fast.
Reviewed by 'Rocco N' on January 27, 2011
Will never go back! End of story, the owner walked around the place with an unlit cigar in his mouth, no class.
Reviewed by 'RPFESQ' on September 20, 2010
Our visits to the new location in Carmel have been worthwhile. Brick-oven pizza is crispy with just the right balance of sauce and toppings. Entrees are carefully prepared and flavorful. Specials are worth exploring. When dining-in, the owner makes you feel like you're family. BYOB. Generous portions. Arrive early on weekends or be ready for a wait. Plastic Coke pizza-shop glasses detract from the dining experience. Service is friendly & fast.
Reviewed by 'Lisa C' on October 30, 2009
Expensive for amount of food you receive. Pizza was bland, entrees average. Cramped space--be prepared to hear the conversatins of the people at the next table.
Reviewed by 'Donald N' on September 17, 2009
Excellent wood burning stove made pizza's. All of the food is prepared like Mama made it. Strongly recommend getting there early if you are dinning it. Seating is limited during the colder months.
Reviewed by 'Marisa S' on February 2, 2009
The owner/waiter is rude and ill-manored. Pizza was average and the cut of veal was terrible. I was freezing, sitting next to the door, and when I asked to be moved, i was told to "relax."
| 
